My Corn Fed Country Boy LOVES Custard Pie, so I have been on the hunt for “THE” Custard Pie recipe. It’s taken me some time, some flops and some “ALMOST got it’s” before I did it. Today, I achieved THE Custard Pie, and here it is!
Custard Pie
{click title to print}
Ingredients
- 4 whole Large Eggs
- ⅔ cups Sugar
- 2-⅔ cups Whole Milk
- 2 teaspoons Vanilla
- ½ teaspoons Salt
- 1/2 teaspoon Nutmeg, a scant measuring
- Cinnamon
Prepare your favorite 10 inch pie crust and par-bake it. My favorite is Easy Push Crust, found here. Then, continue below:
Preheat oven to 450*. Beat eggs slightly with wire whisk before adding in all remaining ingredients, except cinnamon.
Fill your par baked crust carefully with egg mixture and cover generously in cinnamon. Slide into oven, careful not to slosh, and bake for 20 minutes.
Turn down oven to 350* and bake 15 minutes more. Pie should jiggle, but not slosh when you test it.
Cool 2 hours before serving. This will be safe for a total of 4 hours on the counter and can be served room temperature the first night. Don’t be worried, it is also great served cold from the fridge the next day, in fact, that’s how some prefer it!
Dig in!
On to Weekend Potluck, where friend and foodies meet, all weekend long!
The recipe with the most clicks ~
Cake Batter Dip by Forkful of Comfort
Recipes that caught our eye ~
Tangy Cilantro Jalapeno Lime Coleslaw by Serena Bakes Simply from Scratch
No-Mess Wonton Tacos by Crumbs and Chaos
And, a personal favorite ~
Lime Swirled Icebox Cookies by Shugary Sweets
If you were featured today, please feel free to grab the red “featured” button from my sidebar.
Your hosts ~
- The Country Cook~ Brandie
- Baking Bad~ Hilary
- Meet Penny ~ Tabitha
- 4 Little Fergusons~ Tonya
Remember that when you link up, it shows on all FOUR blogs. Plus…
We TWEET. We PIN. We LIKE.
We want you to get as much exposure as possible so that your time here is well invested.Linky Guidelines: If you wish for us to promote your recipe or want to be a featured recipe, you must follow these instructions. Please link up to your exact post and not the main page to your blog. Also, LINK BACK HERE from your post so that others can find the fun. (Need help linking back? Read this.) You can use the button or a direct link within your post. If you have a recipe to share, please be sure that you are following ALL co-hosts (The Country Cook, Baking Bad, 4 Little Fergusons, AND Meet Penny) by either RSS feed, Daily Email Digest, Facebook or Twitter. Thanks so much for participating!
Click the link below to be taken to a whole new page of deliciousness!



I have never eaten custard pie…it looks really good though. Thank you for hosting each week…have a great weekend:-)
Thanks for the feature!!! And hosting!!
Hi, I stumbled upon your blog a little while ago, and I’m vivid reader now ;)
Wow, I never eaten a Custard Pie.. didn’t even know it exists. LOL. But it does look delicious. Really. Maybe I should try it sometime.
Keep up this awesome blog!
Thank you so much! :)
Once again that looks delicious!
Happy weekend!
Happy Weekend to you, Diane!
Thank you so much for the feature! I love attending every week and seeing what everyone has in store! Your custard pie looks devine by the way!
Whoa–that custard pie looks so dang good!! My husband loves custard pie, so I might have to give your recipe a whirl.
Could you give me some idea of how much cinnamon you use?
I cover the whole top in it, probably a couple Tablespoons!
That’s such a great looking pie. The ingredients are so simple. I can’t believe I haven’t made one.
I also love custard pie and can’t wait to try your recipe. This will definitely be on my next to-do list.